Uncategorized – Page 33 – Anent Scottish Running

St Peter’s AAC Inter-Club Sports

Posted on September 25, 2017 by Admin

Probably the biggest relay meeting held in Scotland was the inter-club championship help in Glasgow in June which had at least five relays and at one point six as an essential part of the programme.

Bobby Graham

There have always been clubs in Scotland that do sterling work for the sport and then just disappear, almost without trace. Perhaps because the spark that created them has left the sport for whatever reason, perhaps because good as they were the club was in the shadow of a much bigger outfit whose sheer size and momentum prevailed. One such club was St Peter’s AAC which was based in the west end of Glasgow. The club competed well and contributed to athletics in the area but its real contribution was in the organisation of the big Inter-Club Meeting in June every year from 1928 to 1936.

Held on 2nd June, 1928 at Shawfield Park and before a crowd of 2000 people, there were to start with four open races – 100 yards handicap, 100 yards scratch, 440 yards handicap youths and half-mile handicap. The real business however was the inter-club contest which involved six relays, a four miles team race, and five field events. All branches were involved: sprinters, middle distance men, long distance runners, hurdlers, jumpers and throwers all were catered for. The trophy awarded was the “News of the World Challenge Trophy”. That particular newspaper sponsored many events across the length and breadth of Britain with the four multi-stage inter-city relays being the biggest and best. The event would settle into the second Saturday in June at Celtic Park, but the first was on the first Saturday.

It was reported on in the ‘Glasgow Herald’ as follows:

“It was generally expected that with the strength at their disposal, Maryhill Harriers would take pride of place at the meeting organised by that enterprising young club, St Peter’s. In the mid-distances with D McLean, WH Calderwood, W McRoberts, GP Inglis and A Mair they have a string that no other club can compete with at the moment, and winning four of the six relay flat events they won the trophy with a comfortabkle margin from the West of Scotland Harriers. The last-named club, for whom PW Brown confirmed his fine running of a week ago, were not over-weighted in the shorter distances, and won two events, the quarter mile and the mile, due in no small measure to smart understanding at the hand over.

The best race of the afternoon was the three miles team event. Here only one point separated Maryhill and Plebeian Harriers, and it was Donald MacLean’s final burst to the tape that earned the former their victory in this event. The mile champion ran also in the two miles, and here the expected duel between him and JD Hope did not materialise, as he took over with a lead of 20 yards and this was an impossible start for Hope to concede. Hope, making his first appearance of the season, showed good form, and A Nicolson, the Scottish champion, had a creditable effort in the weight of 42 ft 11 ins. Interesting too was the running of J Crawford, the Queen’s Park footballer. He has cultivated a new style which does not please the critics, and any increase in speed which he has made has been at the expense of smoothness.”

It will be noted straight away the some names appear more than once – in inter-clubs there are always demands made on athletes to ‘double up’ no matter which decade in athletics history we are speaking about. The quality of these athletes was very high indeed and the results of relays and team races are noted here.

440 yards relay (4 x 110): 1. West of Scotland (PW Brown, JG Scott, S Bernstein, AF Clarke). 2. Maryhill H; 3. Shettleston H.

880 yards relay (4 x 220): 1. Maryhill (WP Andreoli, DE Duncan, T McLean, R Kennedy); 2. West of Scotland; 3. Bellahouston H.

Mile Relay (4 x 440): 1. West of Scotland (AF Clarke, PW Brown, H Elliott, JD Hope); 2. Maryhill; 3. Shettleston.

Two Miles Relay (4 x 880): 1. Maryhill (W Roberts, WH Calderwood, D Sharp, D MacLean); 2. West of Scotland; 3. Cameron Highlanders

Four Miles Relay (4 x 1 Mile): 1. Maryhill Harriers (GP Inglis, T Cowan, WH Calderwood, D MacLean; 2. Garscube H; 3. Camerons.

480 yards hurdles relay (4 x 120): 1. West of Scotland (J Porteous, AF Clarke, T Clark, C Clark); 2. 2nd Cameronians

Three Miles Team Race: 1, Maryhill ( D MacLean 1, D McL Wright 4, WH Calderwood 5: 10 pts); 2. Plebeian (Combe 2, Gunn 3, Connolly 6)

Championship Cup: 1. Maryhill 20 pts; 2. West of Scotland 13 pts; 3. Cameronians 11 pts.

As far as the field events went, Maryhill only won the high jump while the Field Events Club won the hammer, 2nd Cameronians took the long jump, Glasgow Police won the putting the weight.

If 1928 was a success, 1929 was a revelation of the interest taken in an inter-club contest by Scotland’s athletes. The meeting was on 8th June and all cncerned were assessing the athletes form for the SAAA Championships which were to be held on 22nd June – just two weeks later.

It is pleasant to be able to record in these supposedly materialistic days, that 15 clubs, representing some 500 athletes, can be fund willing to take part in an inter-club contest where individual glory plays second part to the team spirit. It fell to the lot of St Peter’s, one of the youngest but one of the most enterprising clubs in the Western area, to discover this fact a year ago, and the success which attended their meeting at Scotstoun on Saturday demonstrated that the clubs were again more than anxious to participate in a meeting of this kind.

The competition throughout was keen and it was not until the very last event on the programme, the broad jump, that victory rested with Glasgow University by a bare margin of 2 points over Maryhill Harriers who were winners a year ago at Shawfield.

In a meeting of this kind it is somewhat difficult to assess individual values, but several of the candidates for championship honours acquitted themselves well, and we had the added satisfaction of seeing two Scottish champions, in James Crawford and KM Smith, in action for the first time this season. The Queen’s Park flyer, who ran in Shettleston’s colours in the two shorter relays, moved well enough to suggest he will be fit and ready for June 22nd. He was beaten in the final leg of the 440 relayn by JA Robb on practically equal terms, but an impartial survey of the race suggests that this was due as much to an indifferent change-over as to any inferiority in pace. ….

In the distance events the reserve strengt of Maryhill Harriers was apparent, their victory in the mile, two miles and four miles being earned somewhat easily. Donald MacLean, the Scottish champion, moved in freer style than in his previous races this season, and his mile was unofficially times at 4 min 41 3-5th sec, so that there is every hope that he may be back to form ere the championships. In these sections WH Calderwood, C Freshwater and J Hood all acquitted themselves well, and among the younger runners, none did better than A Fisher of West of Scotland. To defeat a tried performer like AH Blair was no mean feat. ….. “

The report goes on to discuss the three miles team race, won by Plebeian Harriers over Springburn by three points with Maryhuill thirs. Meeting relay results:

480 yards relay: 1. Glasgow University (Wright, Smith, Borland, Robb). 2. Shettleston H. 3. West of Scotland Harriers

Half-mile relay: 1. Glasgow University (Wright, Smith, Borland, Robb) 2. West of Scotland H; 3. Maryhill H

One Mile Relay: 1. Maryhill H (Duncan, Turner, Allison, Devlin); 2. Bellahouston H; West of Scotland H

Two Miles Relay: 1. Maryhill H (Herbert, McRoberts, Blair, Calderwood); 2. Glasgow University; 3. Shettleston H

Four Miles Relay: 1. Maryhill H (Maclean, Kellas, Blair, Calderwood); 2. Glasgow University; 3. Bellahouston H

480 yards hurdles relay: 1. 2nd Cameronians; 2. West of Scotland Harriers; 3. Shettleston H

Three Miles team race: 1. Plebeian Harriers (Gunn 1, Rayne 3, Lamont 11 = 14 points); Springburn Harriers (J Stevenson 4, R Allison 6, A Stevenson 7 = 17 pts; 3. Maryhill 28 pts.

Such was the emphasis on the inter-club nature of the event, that even the field events were included but with the results calculated as for distance track races. eg Maryhill won the high jump with the aggregate height of two representatives being 11′ 0″ (Smith 5′ 8″, Bulloch 5′ 4″) with the Field Events Club being second with a total height of 10′ 8″ and the 2nd Cameronians third with 10′ 2″. With three throws and two jumps, the field events were important in deciding the destination of the event. The News of the World Trophy in 1929 went to the University who had a total of 16 pts, from Maryhill on 14 pts and the Cameronians on 9 pts.

Walter Gunn, Plebeian Harriers

The St Peter’s Inter-Club contest was held on 14th June in 1930 at Celtic Park, and success continued unabated. Glasgow University again won the trophy, defeating Maryhill – but not until the last event, the javelin this time, was over. Edinburgh University won that from Glasgow University with Shettleston third and it was good enough to see the Glasgow students win with exactly the same scores and points difference as the previous year – their 16 points defeating Maryhill’s 14 by two with Edinburgh University two further adrift on 12 pts. The attendance was reported as ‘moderate’ but that was not the point of such an event. There were some changes in the format – one was that the Four Miles Relay became a One Mile team race. It was still part of the inter club but saved a fair bit of time on the programme! Results of the relays:

440 yards relay: 1. Maryhill H (Anderson, McBride, t McLean, Turner); 2. Shettleston H; 3. Glasgow University

880 yards relay: 1. Glasgow University (Murdoch, ? , Wright, Borland); 2. Maryhill; 3. Edinburgh University

Mile relay: 1. Springburn Harriers (McLaughlin, Scott, Mackill, Devon); 2. Glasgow University; 3. West of Scotland

Two Miles relay: 1. Maryhill (Muir, Blair, Calderwood, D MacLean); 2. Edinburgh University; 3. West of Scotland H

480 yards hurdles relay: 1. Edinburgh University (Decker, Campbell, Barker, Holmes); 2. Field Evcents Club; [GUAC second but disq)

One Mile Team Race: 1. Maryhill Harriers (MacLean 1, Muir 3, Blair 4); 2. Glasgow University AC; 3. Bellahouston

Three Miles team race: 1. Maryhill Harriers (D Wright 1, Muir 3, Robertson 4); 2. Bellahouston H; 3. Garscube H.

Glasgow University won the trophy largely because Maryhill Harriers got almost no points at all in the field events wheras the students picked a couple of firsts, a second and a third.

The changes referred to above were interesting in their own right:

a. open events had increased in number from four in the first match to eight this time round plus two cycle races.

b. The events were 100 yards, 440 yards (both handicaps), 100 yards junior scratch; 100 yards novice scratch;

c. There were three races for women, one of which was a relay -100 yards, 220 yards; 440 yards relay . Edinburgh University and Maryhill Harriers were the strongest women’s teams with Glasgow University also providing a placed runner.

d. Celtic Park had a concrete cycle track outside the cinder track and so for the first time it was possible to hold a 440 yards cycle race and a one mile cycle race without interfering with the state of the track.

The meeting on 13th June 1931 was again held at Celtic Park and there were again innovations and changes to the format.

Results:

440 yards relay: 1. Maryhill H (Turner, McBride, Stewart, Hamilton); 2. Dublin Metropolitan Garda; 3. Shettleston H

880 yards relay: 1. Maryhill H (Turner, Brown, McBride, Hamilton); 2. Shettleston Harriers; 3. West of Scotland H

Mile Relay: 1. Maryhill H (A Edmiston, Lieut A Harvey, P Dolan, R Hamilton); 2. Springburn H; 3. Dublin Metropolitan Garda

Two Miles Relay: 1. Maryhill H (McNiven, Wilson, Calderwood, MacLean); 2. Springburn H; 3. Shettleston H

480 yards hurdles relay: 1. Dublin Metropolitan Garda; 2. Fied Events Club; 3. West of Scotland H

Mile Team Race: 1. Maryhill H (MacLean 2, Calderwood 4, Blakely 6); 2. Plebeian H; 3. Springburn H

Three Miles Team Race: 1. Maryhill H (Muir 4, Blakely 5, Blair 9); 2. Heriots FP; 3. Springburn H

Two Miles Junior Relay: 1. Plebeian H (Blackwood, Armstrong, Black, Illingworth); 2. Garscube H; Victoria Park.

Two things stand out here – one is the addition of yet another relay – the two miles junior event (4 x 880), which seems to prove the popularity of the format; and the arrival on the club scene of Victoria Park AAC. The club had been formed only one year earlier. We can go further and note that the events for women were now over 100 yards open, 100 yards (confined to St Peter’s), 220 yards, half mile and 440 yards relay. This time there were more clubs involved – Shettleston, Bellahouston and Maryhill were all represented. As for the contest – Maryhill won with 24 points, from Dublin Metropolitan Garda on 19 1/2 pts with Shettleston well back on 9 pts. Previously regarded as the unofficial club championship of Scotland, the entry of the Irish team maybe complicated things. Maryhill had made a clean sweep of the track events, bar the Junior Two Miles relay for which they had not entered a team and they competed better in the field events than the year before with 2nd in the broad jump and hammer, plus 3rd in the high jump and weight. The absence of the University teams was to be regretted since they had their own championships at Craiglockhart that same Saturday

The Inter-club competition the following year was held on 4th June 1932, and was again at Celtic Park. It had moved about between the first three Saturdays in June sinceits inception because of the other events being held. The Queen’s Park Sports were on the first Saturday and St peter’s wanted to keep clear of that date, but if the Irish international was on the second Saturday, they had to move back a week. Or forward. The University championships were usually on the second Saturday of the month so it was sometimes better to go to the third Saturday. However, the report on the ’32 version started as follows: “The strength of the Glasgow University team in the field events made the Students’ victory in the inter-club contest at the St Peter’s AAC meeting at Celtic Park on Saturday afternoon much more decisive than was anticipated. They actually collected 17 of the 18 points at stake in this section and although Edinburgh were handicapped by the absence of their champion, RW MacKay, the relative placings of the two teams at the finish should give the teams every encouragement for their meeting in the inter-university contest at Westerlands on Saturday first. Glasgow University’s final tally was 30 points, Maryhill Harriers being runners-up with 18, while Edinburgh University and Springburn tied for third place with 5 points each. In only one of the ten events, the three mile team race, did Glasgow fail to score, and they never fell behind second place.”

440 yards relay: 1. Glasgow University (Stead, Clark, Kitchen and McCush) ; 2. Edinburgh University; 3. Bellahouston Harriers

880 yards relay: 1. Maryhill H (Brown, McBride, Bell, Dolan); 2. Glasgow University; 3. Victoria Park

Mile relay: 1. Glasgow University (Glen, Young, Barlow, Borland); 2. Springburn H; 3. Maryhiull H

Two Miles relay: 1. Glasgow University (Glen, Barr, Wynne Roberts, Murison); 2. Maryhill H; 3. Springburn H

480 yards hurdles relay: 1. Glasgow University (Selkirk, Souter, Taylor, Kitchin) walked over.

One Mile team race: 1. Maryhill H (Calderwood 1, MacLean 4, Muir 5); 2. Glasgow University; 3. Plebeian Harriers

Three Miles team race: 1. Maryhill Harriers (Blakely 1, DM Robertson 3, W Nelson 4); 2. Plebeian H; 3. Garscube H

There were two records set at the meeting – Tom Blakely of Maryhill set a new Scottish record for three miles of 14 min 38 1-5th sec and Constance Johnston, SWAAA champion set a new record for the half mile of 2 min 24 1-5th sec. The open track events were held but this time there were no cycle races at all and the two miles junior relay had been dropped.

“For the fourth time in the six years that have elapsed since the meeting was first instituted, Glasgow University won the inter-club contest held at Celtic Park on Saturday afternoon under the auspices of the St Peter’s club. This has come to be regarded as the unofficial all-round championship and a test of the strength of the clubs in track, field and heavy events. Let it be said that the Glasgow students by gaining first place with their total of 22 points fully deserved their claim to be the best team in Scotland, as in only one of the 12 events on the programme – the three miles team race – did they fail to secure points. They won four events (Mile relay, high jump, broad jump, javelin), finished second in three (880 yards relay, two miles relay and putt), their third placings being in 440 yards relay, 480 hurdles relay, one mile team race and hammer. “

Glasgow Police were second and Maryhill and Edinburgh University tied for third. Results:

440 yards relay: 1. Maryhill H (Turner, McBride, Bell, Brown); 2. Edinburgh University; 3. Glasgow University.

880 yards relay: 1. Maryhill H (Brown, Bell, McBride, Turner); 2. Glasgow University; 3. Springburn Harriers

Mile relay: 1. Glasgow University (Murray, Wright, Young, Glen); 2. Glasgow Police; 3. Springburn H

Two Miles relay: 1. Glasgow Police (Wilson, Lyons, Davie, Scott); 2. Glasgow University; 3. Maryhill H

One Mile team race: 1. Shettleston Harriers (Sutherland 2, McCubbin 3, Young 12); 2. Garscube H; 3. Glasgow University.

Three Miles team race: 1. Plebeian H (Tombe 1, Gunn 2, Armstrong 5); 2. Maryhill H; 3. Garscube H.

Although there was no team in the team race from Heriot’s FP, JF Wood was first to finish in the three miles in 15 min 7 3-5th sec.

JF Wood, Heriot’s FP

16th June 1934: For the third year in succession and the fifth time since the inception of the event in 1928, Glasgow University in the inter-club contest held under the auspices of St Peter’s on Saturday proved themselves to be the best of the Scottish clubs in an all-round trial of strength in track, field and heavy events. They finished first of the twelve clubs competing, and in only two of the twelve events, the mile and the three miles team events, did they fail to register points. Their total of 22 points was taken from firsts in the 880 yards relay, 480 yards hurdles relay and the high jump, seconds in the 440 yards relay, one mile relay, two miles relay, high jump, putt and hammer, and a third in the javelin. Shettleston, who alone of the Harrier clubs have devoted much time to the field and heavy events, were a good second with 14 points, and it is to be noted that this section of the club, led by JK Braid and ER Walker, collected all but three of the total. Maryhill was third with 8 points, and Glasgow Police and West of Scotland tied for fourth with 7 points. It ios pleasant to see the last named, one of our oldest clubs, coming back into the limelight after several seasons of partial eclipse.”

Results:

440 yards relay: 1. Maryhill H (Turner, McBride, Brown, Williamson) ; 2. Glasgow University; 3. Bellahouston H

880 yards relay: 1. Glasgow University (Bishop, Stone, Robertson, Murdoch); 2. Maryhill H; 3. Glasgow Police

Mile relay: 1. Springburn Harriers (C Campbell, Carson, McKell, A Campbell); 2. Glasgow University; 3. West of Scotland H

Two Miles Relay: 1. Maryhill H (Graham, MacLean, Scholes, Calderwood); 2. Glasgow University; 3. Victoria Park

4 x 120 yards hurdles relay: 1. Glasgow University (Chassels, JA Kitchin, TH Souter, AS Kitchin); 2. Shettleston H; 3. West of Scotland

One Mile team race: 1. Plebeian Harriers (Gunn1, McGregor 4, Robertson 8); 2. Shawfield Harriers; 3. Shettleston H

Three Miles team race: 1. Garscube Harriers (Bennett 3, Lindsay 5, DB Brooke 7); 2. Shettleston H; 3. Springburn H.

In the field events, Shettleston Harriers won the shot and the javelin, Glasgow University won the broad jump West of Scotland won the high jump and Glasgow Police won the hammer event. It should be pointed out in defence of the Harrier clubs, that one of the reasons they did not embrace the field and heavy events was probably a lack of appropriate facilities. The Universities with exclusive use of Westerlands and Craiglockhart with equipment for all the events available on demand. They also of course had the time for training and in addition the actual work done by most athletes in the shipyards, factories and coal mines was more physically demanding than the life of most students. The university teams might well have won the championship in any case – they had some superb athletes – but the above factors (access to facilities, less time for training and a more physically demanding lifestyle) are offered in defence of the harriers.

When St Peter’s held the event at Celtic Park on 8th June 1935, the Inter-Universities Championship was held at Craiglockhart in Edinburgh and this not only reduced the number of teams competing in Glasgow, but made the championship more open than it had been for several years. It was held on a wet and heavy track with nasty cross-winds but went ahead as usual. Results:

440 yards relay: 1. Garscube Harriers (Walker, J McIsaac, JT McIsaac, Pitcairn); 2. West of Scotland H; 3. Maryhill H.

880 yards relay: 1. Bellahouston H (Thomson, Gallagher, Lawn, Fraser); 2. West of Scotland; 3. Maryhill.

Mile relay: 1. Maryhill H (Terry, Cairns, Scholes, Morrison); 2. Victoria Park; 3. West of Scotland.

Two Miles relay: 1. Maryhill H (MacLean, Morrison, Osborn, Calderwood); 2. Victoria Park; 3. Plebeian H.

480 yards hurdles relay: 1. Bellahuston H (CG Gordon, Arnott, Wyper, OG Gordon); West of Scotland finished but were disualified.

One Mile team race: 1. Maryhill H (MacLean 1, Osborne 7, Calderwood 8); 2. Garscube H; 3. Plebeian H.

Three Miles team race: 1. Bellahouston H (Campbell 1, Lamb 2, Mowat 5); Maryhill H; 3. Plebeian H

Championship: 1. Maryhill H 18 pts; 2. West of Scotland 17 pts

There was no St Peter’s AC Inter-Club contes held in 1936 – or in 1937 or 1938 either. There were so many other meetings that they may have been crowded out of the calendar. There were only three Saturdays available in June: the fourth was always the SAAA championships, and on that Saturday there were a couple of minor meetings such as Lugar Sports. The first Saturday in June was always the Quen’s Park FC Sports which was a very attractive draw for athletes and the other regular meetings were the Singer’s Factory Sports at Clydebank and the Alloa meeting. It would have been hard for a club to get all their best men out for a meeting such as the inter-club on that date. The second Saturday was not any easier and that was traditionally the date for St Peter’s event: the Universities usually had their championships on that date and we hav seen how important their presence was for the Glasgow meeting. It was also unfortunate that the Babcock’s Sports had been going for five or six years by 1936 and it was offering the Empire Exhibition Trophy to the club with most points at the meeting which had two relays (4 x 100 and medley) and a track team race in addition to points for places in most events on the programme. It almost duplicated some aspects of the St Peter’s programme and it was easier to forward a team. And it was on the same day. On the third Saturday it was the Glasgow Police Sports: formerly a professional meeting it had joined the amateur ranks and proved to be very successful with some really good relays (normally two per programme). There was also an Edinburgh meeting on the third Saturday and the Dalmuir United FC had their sports on that date.

The situation for St Peter’s was one where they had to decide to either

a. Keep the date they had which clashed with the Universities champ[ionships, and, possibly more important, with Babcock and Wilcox Sports with the Empire Exhibition Trophy’; or

b. Move back a week and face the challenge of the Queen’s Park Sports which most athletes found quite attractive;; or

c. Move forward and clash with Glasgow Police Sports being held at Ibrox; or

d. Stop holding the meeting.

They were a small club, crowds were usually described as ‘moderate’ with no figures given, and they maybe just did not have the personnel or the drive to continue. However it turned out, there were no more inter-clubs held by St Peter’s. This was a pity because it was at a time when there were no track leagues of any form and whole club competition has a lot to commend it. It filled a gap, and right well did it do it.

Queen’s Park Sports: 1926 – 1929

Posted on August 29, 2017 by Admin

The Queen’s Park Sports of 1925 had been very successful with many of the top athletes participating. The meeting of 1926 also had several top men in action across the board. Held on 5th June in brilliant sunshine and before a crowd of approximately 7000 spectators, Tom Riddell was the top performer – or the ‘feature of the meeting’ as the Herald report had it. He finished second in the half-mile and defeated CB Mein (above)in the first stage of the inter-city relay race. This played no small part in Glasgow winning the event for the first time. The Two Miles Harriers Race was won by Walter Calderwood of Maryhill Harriers with Frank Stevenson of Motherwell second, Charlie Freshwater and Dunky Wright of Caledonia AC third and fourth. Caledonia AC was set up to be a ‘club of champions’ with W Sans Unkles and Dunky Wright the main protagonists. It only lasted for the one season – Charlie Freshwater had signed up from Clydesdale Harriers and Wright had come from Clydesdale by way of Shettleston before going on to jon Maryhill when the Caledonia adventure came to naught. The club won the team race from Maryhill Harriers. Celtic beat Rangers in the final of the five-a-sides by 2 goals to none. In the open events, Walter Lawn won the 100 yards and was third in the 220 yards – Lawn went on to have a printing business that provided numbers for the SAAA championships for many years as well as for most open meetings of any size.

In 1927 the club sports were held on June 4th and the report in the ‘Glasgow Herald’ read:

The weather and ground conditions which prevailed at the Queen’s Park club’s annual sports on Saturday afternoon were not of the kind conducive to to exceptional performances, yet the sport throughout was interesting and the times recorded were distinctly good. The outstanding event at the meeting, both in point of competition and on merit, was the invitation quarter-mile, and in winning from two yards in 51 4-5th sec, RB Hoole gave a glimpse of better form than he has hitherto shown in the West. He had to fight all the way for his victory against RT Hollinger of Plebeian Harriers and JC Hamilton the Glasgow University champion, and the manner in which he secured victory on the tape from the first named, was a tribute to his pace, stamina and judgment.

JD Hope, the champion, was not suited by the conditions. He is of a build better suited to calm than storm, and he was never concerned with the ultimate issue. Hoole and Hope were down to meet later in the afternoon in the inter-city relay race, but the withdrawal of HC Maingay from the Edinburgh team robbed this promised trial of skill on level terms in the quarter-mile section, and also that of RD Allison and R McLean in the furlong, of much of their interest, as CB Mein, who sportingly stepped to the vacancy was obviously not fit and accordingly not able to hold RB McIntyre who ran the half-mile for Glasgow. The ground lost there was never regained by Edinburgh and we will have to wait untl the championships to have the merits of these opponents accurately tested. Enough was seen, however, to suggest that both furlong and quarter-mile championships will prove exceedingly interesting.

As is usual, the student element was strongly represented in the prize list. In addition to Hoole, AF Clarke and GPS Macpherson occupied first and second places in the hurdles; R Patience of Glasgow won the Mile with something in hand, and A Tindal, also a Gilmorehill student, took second place in the open hundred. Tindal’s achievement in the hundred was somewhat unique, as he has hitherto been regarded as a distance man, and not only did he win the Mile at his University competition, but he took part in the SAAA 10 mile championhip in mid-April. Patience, a strongly built lad, was suited by the conditions in the Mile, but apart from that it was apparent that the handicapper took too lenient a view of the ability which several good judges are convinced he possessed.

T McLean, the Rover Scout, is running well at present. as his victory in the 220 yards following upon his third in the hundred suggests, and another genuine runner, J Calder of Beith Harriers, added another win to the series he has at his credit by capturing the half-mile off 30 yards in 1 min 59 sec. Under the conditions this time was much better than it reads on paper. The three miles revealed a very level degree of merit between Maryhill Harriers and Monkland Harriers, the first named being winners by one point only, and the issue depending on the efforts of the third man in each team. It was all the more rgrettable therefor that the race should be marred by a series of incidents which were, to say the least, not creditable to the runners concerned. It was all the more welcome that Donald McLean, the Maryhill Harrier who was first man home, was not in the trouble and his win was decisive enough to suggest that he is to be a strong candidate for a title at the championships in three weeks hence.”

There was no meeting reported for 1928 but the event was only resting and it was back on the usual Saturday in 1929.

On 1st June 1929, J Suttie Smith from Dundee wanted to attempt a new Scottish record: he was a top class internationalist on the track and over the country with several national titles to his credit and Queen’s Park regulars were keen to see him in action. “Chief interest in the meeting of Queen’s Park at Hampden lay in the attempt made by J Suttie Smith upon the existing Scottish native record for two miles. A special handicap had been framed for the occasion, and had the champion been able to head WJ Gunn , who ran off 85 yards, he might have been able to accomplish it, the Plebeian Harrier’s winning time being 9 min 31 1-5th sec. As it was Smith failed to do this, his time for the distance being 2 3-5th sec seconds worse than McLean’s existing figures of 9 min 31 sec.

Smith did not appear to be moving too freely in the first three laps, but ran well in the closing stages. The times in the open races were fast, and it appears now that to win an open sprint even-time is necessary, judging by what happened at the Maryhill meeting and also at Hampden. Two juniors of last season figured successfully in these events. AD Turner of Maryhill Harriers who had almost a monopoly in his class last year, made a bright debut as a senior, as he ran second in the 100 yards, and won the furlong in 22 4-5th sec, while R Davie of Springburn Harriers, in his first public essay over the distance captured the half-mile in 1 min 58 3-5th sec. Both will win further races.

Donald McLean again turned out in the Mile, but again ran indifferently. His clubmate WH Calderwood ran well bth in the first class mile and in the relay. The latter event was won by Beith Harriers, who triumphed over Maryhill Harriers and West of Scotland Harriers. The Ayrshire club has two excellent runners in J Calder and TJ McAllister, and this pair contribted largely to their success.”

There were ten track races plus an obstacle race, a high jump and a five-a-side competition won by Partick Thistle from Rangers by two goals to one afterextra time. Because of the very large numbers, the mile was divided into two races – the first class mile for the best runners (ie those with low handicaps) entered, and the second class mile for those with higher handicaps.

1934 Empire Games

Posted on August 29, 2017 by Admin

Scottish Empire Games team, 1934

1934 Empire Games Participation Medal

The 1934 British Empire Games were the second of what is now known as the Commonwealth Games. They were held in England from 4–11 August 1934: London’s Wembley Park was the main arena, although the track cycling events were in Manchester. Seventeen national teams took part, including the Irish Free State (the only Games in which they participated, although at the earlier 1930 Empire Games a single team representing the whole of Ireland competed). London seems to have obtained several Games for reasons other than the straightforward allocation. This was one of the times: the 1934 Games had originally been awarded to Johannesburg in South Africa, but were changed to London because of concerns (particularly from Canada) about the way South Africa would treat black and Asian athletes.

Six sports were featured in the Games: athletics in the White City Stadium; boxing, wrestling, and aquatics (swimming and diving) in the Empire Pool and Arena, Wembley; cycling in Fallowfield Stadium, Manchester; and lawn bowls at Paddington and Temple. Women’s events in athletics were held; in the inaugural Games, the women’s events were found only in swimming. There were twenty one events for men and nine for women.

Although several Scots had competed in Canada in 1930, there was no formal team management and 1934 is regarded as the first year in which a Scottish team was forward.

Hamish Stothard

The Scots athletes and their performances were as follows, Track events first:

100 yards men: Ian Young 3rd, 10.1 sec; David Brownlee 3rd Ht 2; Archie Turner 4th Ht 4

100 yards women: Joan Cunningham, 4th Ht 2; Margaret McKenzie 5th Ht 2; Cathie Jackson, 5th Ht 1; Barbara Barnetson 5th Ht 3

220 yards men: Robin Murdoch 4th (22.8 Ht); Ian Young 5th (22.9 Ht); David Brownlee 5th Ht 2; Archie Turner ran, no details.

220 yards women: Sheena Dobbie 4th Ht 3; Cathie Jackson 5th Ht 1; Margaret McKenzie 5th Ht 2; Barbara Barnetson 5th Ht 3.

440 yards men: Frank Ritchie Hunter 6th (51.1 Hts); Robert Burns Wylde ran Ht 3; Robert H Wallace 5th semi final (50.9 Ht)

880 yards men: James Hamish Stothard 3rd 1:55; Robert Graham 5th Ht 2;

880 yards women: Mildred Storrar 7th.

Mile men: Robert Graham 5th; John Pratt Laidlaw ran Ht 2.

Two Miles Steeplechase: Walter Gunn 6th

Three Miles: John Pratt Laidlaw 7th; James MB Caie 9th.

Six Miles: No Scots

Marathon: Donald Robertson 2nd 2:45:08 ; Duncan Wright 3rd 2:56:20

80 m hurdles women: No Scots

120 yards hurdles men: No Scots

440 yards hurdles men: Frank Ritchie Hunter 1st 56.2 seconds

4 x 110 yards relay men: 3rd (Turner, Brownlee, Young and Murdoch) 43.0

4 x 440 yards relay men: 3rd (Hunter, Stothard, Wallace and Wylde)

4 x 440 yards relay women: dnf (Barnetson, Jackson, Dobbie)

Field Events

Shot Putt Men: No Scots Discus Men: No Scots

Hammer Throw: William McKenzie 3rd 139′ 5″

Javelin Throw Men: No Scots Javelin Throw women: No Scots

High Jump Men: James Fraser Michie 3rd 6’3″ (First three men all stopped at 6’3″).

High Jump Women: No Scots

Long Jump Men: Robert Nelson McQueen Robertson unplaced

Long Jump women: No Scots

Pole Vault Men: Patrick Bruce Bine Ogilvie 6th 11’6″

Triple Jump Men: No Scots

Below: Mildred Storrar’s Track Suit Badsges, courtesy Janet Hardy, as is the photograph at the top of the page

1938 Empire Games

Posted on August 29, 2017 by Admin

The 1938 British Empre Games were held in Sydney, New South Wales in Australia from 5–12 February 1938. They were timed to coincide with the celebrations of the foundation of British settlement in Australia exactly 150 years before. Venues included the Sydney Cricket Ground (the main stadium), the Sydney Sports Ground, the North Sydney Olyumpic Pool and Henson Park. An estimated 40,000 people attended the opening ceremony. Continuing the tradition of the athletes village established in Canada eight years earlier, a competitors’ residential village was established within the grounds of the Sydney Showground. Due to the onset of the Second World War, the games were not held again until 1950.

Ten countries took part – Australia, Bermuda, British Guiana, Canada, Ceylon, England, Fiji, India, New Zealand, Northern Ireland, Scotland, South Africa, Southern Rhodesia, Trinidad and Tobago, Wales. The countries in bold are those that won any medals at all with the top nations being Australia (66), England (44) and Canada (40) while Scotland was eighth with just five medals – two silver and one bronze. In athletics there was one solitary silver – won by David Young in the Discus Throw with a best 43.04 metres – 1.71m behind the winner.

It was the smallest ever Scotland squad up to that point – there was one sprinter, two distance runners and one field events competitors. The sprinter was Margaret Marie McDowell from Ardeer (SWAAA 100 yards champion in 1937 and again in 1939 + 220 yards champion in 1937, ’38 and ’39) who fourth in Heat three of the 100 yards, and fifth in the second semi-final of the 220 yards. The middle distance runner was Bobby Graham who was 5th in the second heat of the half-mile and so did not qualify for the final, and then he did not finish in the final of the Mile after recording 4:18.8 in his Heat. He did not start in the Three Miles where he was entered. The long distance runner was the wonderful Donald McNab Robertson (second in the 1934 Games marathon) who was fourth in the marathon in 2:42:40. The Glasgow policeman David Young was the only field events athlete to represent Scotland and he was the most successful of the four there – second in the discus salvaged some pride with a silver medal although even he did not compete in all that he had been entered for – he was a ‘dns’ in the shot putt. He was SAAA Discus champion in 1937 and 1938 and then again after the War in 1946 and 1947).

Robertson and Young were both in action on the second day of competition – Monday, 7th February and their events were written up as follows by the ‘Glasgow Herald’.

“D McNab Robertson (Maryhill Harriers) who carried Scotland’s hopes in the marathon, an arduous 26 miles test, could only finish fourth to JL Coleman (South Africa) who won in the really fin time of 2 hours 30 min 49 8-10th sec. There is no official world record for this race, but Coleman’s time was within a minute and a half of K Son’s (Japan) Olympic record time. A Norris, the Polytechnic marathon winner, ran a splendid race to finish second and will win a great deal of satisfaction from the race in beating his old rival Robertson.Norris has also the satisfaction that even had he run as well as he has ever done in his life he would still have been several minutes behind Coleman’s time.

Robertson’s performance however – his time was 2 hr 42 min 40 sec – was particularly praiseworthy as he had been suffering from a poisoned finger, which he had lanced on Sunday, and also found the extremely hot sun which streamed down throughout the race particularly exhausting. The heat was however particularly relished by the South African runners, Coleman and HA Gibson who took third place.

However Scotland gained some consolation in the discus event. David Young, Scotland’s champion discus thrower, took second place in this event. His best throw of 141 ft 1 3/4 in was 4 ft 1 1/2 in better than the previous record set up at the 1934 Games by H Hart of South Africa. A new record however was made by the winner, Eric Coy the Canadian thrower with 146 fet 10 1/2 in. Hart’s record was beaten by both men with their qualifying throws. Young was followed by G Sutherland (Canada) who took third place with 136 ft 01/2 in.

Young could have done a lot better yesterday for he had already thrown a distance of 146 ft 1 in in Australian competition.”

Reporting in the ‘Herald’ of 11th February on the Mile it was noted that there were three Britons in the Final – JWL Alford (Wales), R Graham Scotland) and RW Eales (England) before the actual report which read:

“Graham was content to take second place in his Mile heat. Unextended he came in second to the Welsh One Mile champion, Alford. After a slow start, Graham, whose best Mile time is 4 min 12 sec, or 0.8 sec quicker than the Games record set by J Lovelock in 1934, quickly took the lead. He was followed by F Barry-Brown, the Australian, with Alford lying third. At the half-way Graham was still striding away effortlessly in the lead. The order was unchanged except that Allen had dropped to sixth. Now Alford overtook Barry-Brown without difficulty and lay a close second to the Scottish champion. With a quarter of a mile to go the Welshman speeded up but Graham did not respond to the challenge. He was content to qualify. Alford passed him at the beginning of the straightand went on to win by 10 yards in 4 min 17 3-10th sec. Graham was four yards ahead of Pullen who took third place.

Graham’s chief opposition in the Final will come from the leaders in the second heat – Gerald Backhouse the Australian Olympic runner, and VP Boot, the young New Zealander who set up a new record for the half-mile on Monday.”

None of the British women qualified for the Final of the 220 yards. McDowell qualified from he heat for the semi-final: “Miss McDowell had taken third place in her first round heat to qualify for the semi-final. The Scottish champion ran a good race in this first round heat. She was drawn on the worst track but qualified easily, being able to slow up considerably towards the finish. The heat was won by Miss J Coleman of Australia in 25.3 sec, beating the Australian record by .2 sec. The Scottish girl was content to take the last qualifying place without exerting herself. In her semi-final heat, Miss McDowell was opposed by Miss M Meagher (Canada) who had won her qualifying heat, Miss Coleman, Miss Wearne (Australia) who had taken second place to Miss Meagher and Miss Susan Stokes, the London girl. Miss Meagher won in 25 1-10th sec with Mis Coleman, half a yardbehind, second. Miss McDowell was last.”

The Mile final was on the last day and the report merely said that Graham disappointed. After setting a fast pace he lagged behind and did not finish. There was no word about whether he had been injured, ill or otherwise disadvantaged by fate.

Bobby Graham

1930 Empire Games

Posted on August 22, 2017 by Admin

The first British Empire Games were held in Hamilton, Ontario in Canada between 16th and 23rd August in 1930 with a total of 400 competitors. They were a great success and many of their innovations were adopted by the Olympic movement which watched this new competition with interest. eg there hd never been a podium for the awards to be presented while the flag was unfurled for the winner. The Olympics had the flags, but no podium and they first used a podium in 1932. Where did the British Empire Games come from? What were their origins? My main source for what follows in “the Commonwealth Games” by Brian Oliver, although other sources have also been consulted.

Bobby Robinson, above, was born in Peterborough, Ontario in 1888 and was an important figure in the newspaper business and a well connected businessman. He was known as a dynamic and aggressive campaigner who in 1929 first set out his plans for the Games. He and a fellow businessman, Howard Crocker, had been discussing ways to get their athletes more and better competition and Crocker had mentioned the Festival of Empire held in London in 1911 for King George V’s coronation; he also mentioned the ‘Pan Britannic Festival of Culture and Sport’ dreamt up by J Astley Cooper in the early 1890’s. Robinson liked what he had heard and is said to have begun planning from then for the Empire Games.

He was further spurred on by the perceived treatment of Canadian athletes at the 1928 Olympics in Amsterdam. Mainly by the Americans and Germans. When Percy He was interviewed by the Toronto Star writer Lou Marsh who reported that “as a result of the dominance, real or imagined, by Germany and America at the Olympic meet, … Robinson finally boiled over and, after consultation with other Canadian officials, met representatives of the other British teams.” Among his complaints were the Williams incident mentioned above, the fact that the Americans were allowed to train on the Olympic track while the Canadians were not, a disputed verdict in the women’s 100m which was given to the Americans when Canadians thought it should go the other way, and a direct insult by Avery Brundage of America to a Canadian official. These comments of course only added fuel to the fire of rivalry between the two nations, and , maybe unfortunately, the official correspondence preceding the Hamilton meeting has been lost.

However, in January 1929, Robinson asked the Hamilton city fathers for $25,000 to run the Games and a further $150,000 to build the stadium and other facilities. Other countries came on board, not without difficulty and the main supporters of Australia, England and New Zealand all stated their intention to be present. In the event, there were 11 nations present.

The sports included athletics, boxing, lawn bowls, rowing, swimming, and wrestling. The opening ceremonies and many events were held at the Civic stadium in east Hamilton. The games were opened by the Governor General of Canada, Lord Willingdon on the 16 August. As at the Olympic Games, the competitors all marched in behind their national flag but the whole parade was led in by the Union Jack as an indication that they were all part of the British Empire. the oath taken by Percy Williams, on the flag, on behalf of the athletes was “From many parts of the British Empire, we are here assembled as amateur athletes to compete in friendly competition. We pledge our best endeavours to uphold the honour of our country and the glorious traditions of British Sportsmanship.”

Once the games started, Scotland won 17 medals – 2 gold, 3 silver and 5 bronze which placed them fourth behind England (61), Canada (54) and South Africa (17) but ahead of New Zealand (9) and Australia (8). Not bad. There was only one athletics medal – gold for the marathon by Dunky Wright. There was also a gold, a silver and a bronze from boxing, bronze from bowls and finally two silvers and three bronzes from swimming.

The team at departure

Events and Scottish placings John Astley Cooper

Willie Carmichael

Posted on July 19, 2017 by Admin

Willie Carmichael

Willie Carmichael was very influential in Scottish athletics for several decades and yet his name is hardly known in current sporting circles. His career in the sport began in 1921 as a member of Edinburgh Northern Harriers before helping set up Canon Amateur Sporting Club in 1922. He was also a a champion wrestler who went on to manage the Scottish team at the 1934 Empire Games, and such was his involvement with that movement that he he was honoured with an OBE in 1971. He had energy in abundance, a vision equalled by few and was a great servant of Scottish athletics.

1922, Hawkhill. W Carmichael of Edinburgh Northern Harriers

In 1922 at the age of 17, Willie, who had started in athletics a year earlier in 1921 with Edinburgh Northern Harriers, was a founder member of Canon ASC . Although a runner, he was also already a committee man and, representing the club, he was the second man to hold the post of secretary of the East District Cross Country League (which was established in 1924) from 1926 . It was a post he held until 1928 when he went off to India to work. On his return two years later, he became League President from 1930 t0 1934, still as a member of Canon. 1934 was a significant year for Willie: when Canon ASC became Edinburgh Eastern Harriers he was a founder member; and in that same year he was manager of the Scottish wrestling team at the Empire Games in London. The Scottish Amateur Wrestling Association was formed in 1931. By 1938 Kenneth Whitton was President and Willie Carmichael Secretary of SAWA and they were joint team managers at the 1938 Empire Games in Sydney, Australia. (Kenneth Whitton was also an athlete and athletics historian who made several contributons to the official 50th anniversary history of the SAAA). Willie was very active in both sports simultaneously and by 1938, at the age of 36, already had experience of three Empire Games.

Final, Thomas Young Cup. W Carmichael v J Cropper (winner) 1932

As an elected member of the SAAA, he was automatically on the East District Committee of which he was Secretary from 1937 to 1951. President of the Scottish Cross-Country Union in 1937/38, he is better known for his work with the cross-country side of the sport before the War in 1939. The War started in 1939 and athletics was the least of anybody’s problems with the sport on a back burner until 1946.

Even the War couldn’t hinder his interest in the sport. Betwen 1944/45, while Director of Salvage for Northern Ireland, he was a member of the NIAAA committee and chaired the meeting of North and South which formed the Irish Amateur Athletic Board.

Medal for winning the Canon ASC v Kirkcaldy YMCA 2 Miles.

After the War Willie is better known for his work in track and field athletics. He remained on the East District and SAAA Committees and hard as he worked there, he still found time to serve the sport in a multitude of ways. For instance in August 1947 it was decided to publicise the ‘Enterprise Scotland Exhibition’ by organising an Edinburgh to London Relay. There were 26 runners involved and it was a mammoth undertaking – the logistics of providing transport, food, lodgings, etc were difficult enough but there were the added complications of ‘glad handing’ local dignitaries in every town and city they passed through and feeding information and publicity to the Press. The team manager was Willie Carmichael. He wrote about it in the ‘Scots Athlete’ magazine of October/November 1947 where, although he does not make it sound exceptional, it really was a first class piece of organisation and management.

Edinburgh Eastern Harriers, winners of Heriot Athletic Trophy

‘Braw Lads’ Challenge Shield for Mile Relay Race at Galashiels.Braw Lads Sportr

Willie Carmichael, President

That magazine made a point of covering the top athletics meetings of the day in detail – the Rangers Sports, the Glasgow Police and the Edinburgh Highland Games being the major ones. In the June 1947 issue, below the accompanying photograph, it noted:

“William Carmichael (Hon Sec, Eastern District, SAAA) is doing his utmost to make Edinburgh a great centre for amateur athletics. He is responsible for the big 14th June meeting at New Meadowbank, and Edinburgh Corporation Highland Games on Saturday 19th July at Murrayfield.”

Willie worked for the Lighting and Cleansing Department and had organised, among other things, the Edinburgh Lighting and Cleansing Department Open Meetings. When the Edinburgh Highland Games started out in 1947, who better to organise them than Willie Carmichael: I quote from the September, 1949, issue of the Scots Athlete:

A Bouquet for Edinburgh

W Carmichael who was the guiding light in this promotion once again proved his great flair for organising and it was grand to see such a resounding success. The hard-working Eastern District Secretary has the gift of imagination and believes in doing things on a big scale. For instance the appearance of Arthur Wint and Fanny Blankers-Koen would alone have drawn the crowd. But an invitation was also extended to a select British team of athletes and cyclists; and what a team Jack Crump had with him. ………….. But at the end of the day in attempting to recapture once more the highlights of the meeting, perhaps the most striking feature of all was the magnificent enthusiasm of the spectators. The warm sportsmanship of the Edinburgh audience remains a fragrant memory”.

Willie was not just an administrator either although he organised the Edinburgh Games for a total of 31 years. He was a Grade One Judge for all three disciplines of track, jumps and throws and officiated latterly as referee at meetings big and small. eg he officiated at the Rangers Sports from at least 1950 to 1962. In 1948 he worked at the London Olympics as a track judge and as a wrestling judge. He thus officiated as a Judge or official at Scottish open, District, National and International events on the track and over the country. He also officiated on the Edinburgh to Glasgow eight-man road relay. As a reward for his work with the SAAA he was elected President in 1953.

Mr Carmichael centre with Local Authority officials from the North of England

Not only was the man active on the Scottish stage, in 1952 he was a Scottish representative on the British Amateur Athletic Board – this was a three year appointment and it coincided ith his election as President of the SAAA.

So far Willie had had a good career in athletics, but the best was yet to come for Scottish athletics from Willie Carmichael. SAAA triple jump champion Graham MacDonald recalls that as a young competitor in the 1960’s, ” I remember Willie when he was competing in the East District Championships at what was then called New Meadowbank. That was the track constructed next to the Meadowbank Speedway Track used by Edinburgh Monarchs. All gone of course when the Commonwealth Games stadium was built for the 1970 Games. I didn’t know who he was but he looked very dapper and important in his Blue Blazer with a Commonwealth Games badge and wearing a soft hat. Later I realised who he was and at one meeting I overheard him saying to another official ‘we can do it you know’. I guess he was referring to the 1970 Games and I think that he was a driving force if not the main driving force behind Edinburgh’s bid.”
At that time Willie had been Chairman of the the Commonwealth Games Council for Scotland from 1950 to 1955 and followed that with Secretary of the Council. He would hold that post from 1956 to 1979. Willie was General Team Manager for the Vancouver Games in 1954 when Joe McGhee won the dramatic marathon and Bannister defeated Landy in the Mile. There is a little-known story of delay of the return home flight while repairs were carried out to an engine and Willie took the whole team to the pictures. ‘Three Coins in the Fountain’ was the film. would probably inspire many and probably sharpened Willie’s desire to have the Games in Scotland. The ‘hard-working East District secretary with a gift of imagination’ and who ‘believes in doing things on a large scale‘, as Emmet Farrell had it in 1947 was about to tackle his biggest task yet.

The Commonwealth Games in 1970 was an undertaking the likes of which had never been seen in Scotland before: there had been two Olympic Games held in London in times of genuine austerity when Britain took on the Games at short notice, and the Empire Games had been held in London in 1934 and Cardiff in 1958, but they had never been held in Scotland. Willie and Lord Provost Herbert Brechin fought hard to get the Games to Edinburgh. It was not just one bid that they tendered. I quote from the ‘Official History of the IXth British Commonwealth Games’:

“Scotland’s wish to be considered as a host country was presented to the British Commonwealth Games Federation in General Assembly at Melbourne in 1956, at Cardiff in 1958, at Rome in 1960, Perth, Australia, in 1962 (when Scotland was defeated in its quest by Jamaica by a vote of 17 to 16), at Tokyo in 1964, and eventually, successfully, by 18 votes to 11, over New Zealand at Jamaica in 1966, for the 1970 or IXth Games. There the case for Scotland was presented by the Rt Hon Sir Herbert Brechin, then Lord Provost of Edinburgh, and Mr W Carmichael Honorary Secretary of the British Commonwealth Games Council for Scotland, and supported by Councillor Magnus J Williamson (Edinburgh Corporation), and Messrs P Heatly, GA Hunter and DM Wright (Council for Scotland).”

Statisticians Colin Shields and Arnold Black say in their book

“This was not at all just some happy accident. Nothing was left to chance. The meticulous planning began even before Edinburgh beat Christchurch for the right to host the Games at a vote at the Tokyo Olympics in 1964, and the man responsible for so much of it was Edinburgh citizen Willie Carmichael. “More than any other single person, Carmichael brought the Games to Edinburgh,” Colin Shields and Arnold Black write in The Past Is A Foreign Country. “He was Scotland’s wrestling team manager at the inaugural Games at Hamilton in 1930 and had always had the guiding dream of bringing the Games to his native city. “Carmichael not only brought the Games to Edinburgh but organised them as well, acting as full-time director of operations. On a budget of £670,000, he produced the most thrilling and successful sporting extravaganza that Scotland had ever seen. His undoubted talent for organisation and stylish presentation resulted in the Games being judged an overwhelming success both in organisational and sporting terms. “It was by far the largest Games ever held, with 1,383 competitors and 361 officials from the record 42 countries taking part. Meadowbank Stadium, the host for the athletics events, had been constructed especially for the Games at a cost of £2.4 million, including a government grant of £750,000.”

Having learned something at all of these meetings and venues, the bid was sharper every time and by 1966 they must have had known exactly what was required. The voting had been 18 votes for Scotland against 11 for Christchurch, New Zealand. They now had the Games for Scotland. In December 1967 the Appeal Fund was set up with the aim of raising £200,00 towards the costs of organising the Games. Who better to oversee this mammoth task of previously unseen dimensions with the certainty of unexpected problems than Willie Carmichael. The first task was to set up the overall organising structure and it appeared like this:

Willie was the Director of Organisation. Oversight of everything, ex-officio on every committee and committees were set up to deal with Accommodation, Appeals, Catering, Ceremoinial, Queen’s Relay, Communications, Finance, Legal and Concessions, Main Stadium, Medical, Pool, Press and Public Relations, Sports Technical, Tickets, Traffic, Transport, Village, VIP Hospitality and Welcome. 19 sub-committees in all. All had to be staffed, all had to be accountable and all had the responsibility of ensuring that Scotland was portrayed in a good light. All of Scotland’s sports clubs were involved, all interested in sport were involved and every local authority in the land was involved to a greater or lesser degree. It was a massive undertaking. Ultimately though, Willie Carmichael was at the heart of the whole structure.

The Village Committee below was only one of those set up to oversee the various aspects of organisation.

The success of these Games is legendary – from Lachie Stewart winning the 10000m in the rain from Australia’s Ron Clarke on opening night right the way through to Ian Stewart and Rosemary Stirling on the last day of athletics it was a triumph and the competitors from all over the Commonwealth reflected the exuberance of the Scottish hosts. The same tale could be told from all sports – cycling, weight lifting, wrestling, etc all had their moment in the sunshine.

They had been the biggest Games with 42 countries taking part, and they were the first Games to be called the Commonwealth Games. Scotland was fourth on the medal table behind the big countries of Australia, England and Canada.

1970 was run by sports people for sports people and captured the imagination of the whole country, of those interested in sport and those who had never attended a sporting event in their lives. There is a piece of film at

https://scotlandonscreen.org.uk/browse-films/007-000-002-473-c

which shows various key moments of the Games. The description from Scotland on Screen says: “This film features amateur footage from the IXth Commonwealth Games held in Edinburgh in 1970. In the film we see a number of key events from the ceremony, opening with pipe bands marching in front of crowds at the stadium, and the arrival and reception of Prince Philip. There is then Highland dancing, followed by the march past of the attending Commonwealth nations, before an athlete presents a scroll to Prince Philip and doves are released into the air. Various events follow, including a medal being presented to a female athlete. The first race takes place. Scottish athletes, Ian Stewart and Ian John McCafferty, take silver and gold in the 5000 metres. During the closing ceremony, we see the Queen going around stadium in horse drawn carriage before the lyrics of Auld Lang Syne are shown on the scoreboard.”

For those who wish a detailed look at the Games in print, there is a good paper under the title ‘A Spectacular Tableau’ at

https://aspectaculartableau.wordpress.com/2017/02/09/the-edinburgh-1970-british-commonwealth-games-representations-of-identities-nationalism-and-politics/ .

It is an academic publication, includes some gentle criticism and is worth at least a look.

Lachie Stewart (317) tracks Clarke and Taylor in the 10000m

For his part in the winning and organisation of the Games, Willie Carmichael was deservedly awarded the Order of the British Empire (OBE) in 1971 with the citation saying simply ‘Director of Organisation, 1970 Commonwealth Games.’ Commandant of the Scottish team at the Games in New Zealand in 1974, he oversaw a very successful team performance that had clearly fed off the superb 1970 teams. The team was just ovcer 60 strong and Carmichael announced at a dinner in October 1970 that it would be at a cost of £40,000. In twenty first century terms of medals per pound sterling, it was one of the most successful ever!

Officials and administrators for the 1974 Games team

He was also in action in 1978 – his last Commonwealth Games as an official – in Edmonton, Canada and afterwards stepped down from the International Committee. By then he was Honorary Vice-President of the Federation with Prince Philip filling the President’s post.He remained Secretary of the Commonwealth Games Council Scotland until 1979. His interest in wrestling continued right into the 70’s.

But the Games was undeniably the summit of Willie Carmichael’s career in sport – everything he had done beforehand can be seen as preparation for it.

Experience of managing sports teams at the Empire Games from the very first meeting
General Team Manager at the 1954 Empire Games
Experience of m ore than one sport at international level
Administration of domestic championships
Organising big international meetings such as the Edinburgh Highland Games
Albeit on a smaller scale, the multi-faceted and complicated logistics of the Glasgow to London Relay

Although the Games of 1970 were the undoubted apogee of his career in sport, he did not do, as many would have and some did, retire at the top of his game. He stayed with the sport – was he not Secretary of the Commonwealth Games Council for Scotland until 1979? He officiated at many meetings thereafter simply because his love of sport was part of his character. Above all he remained involved with Scottish athletics. At the 1974 Commonwealth Games in New Zealand, he was team commandant, and he was also with the team in 1978 – the year before he stepped down as Council Secretary.

Publicity shot for 1978 Games in Canada

Scottish athletics were lucky to have had him as one of its more faithful servants. When I stepped down from the SAAA Committee, Willie Carmichael was an Honorary Life Vice President having been elected as such in 1958. Even without the 1970 Commonwealth Games he would have had a wonderful career. The work done before during and after made it a totally unique career in the sport.

Some links to extra material: Willie Carmichael’s Commonwealth Gallery : Some photographs from Willie’s career plus several Games pictures

Extract from the History of the Edinburgh Games, 1970: 1. Tasks facing the organisers once the Games were won and

2. Drawings from the various venues. As an indicator of the difference between these wonderful Games and thc current bloated affair

Finally, thanks to all those who helped with this task: Alex Jackson and Graham McDonald who helped get it started and Karl Magee and Ian Mackintosh in the Archive Department in the Stirling University Library. If you are at all interested in the Commonwealth Games of any era, they are a great source of information. Thanks, folks.

Taken at a reception organised by Lothian Regional Council on 22nd August, after the Games which lasted from 3rd to 12th August, – and they’re waiting for a team photo to be taken. Names so far:

Left in shades John Graham; Jim Turnbull wrestler standing third left; Chris Black, hammer, back row with beard is talking to Peter Hoffman, runner;

Seated (2nd row): Drew McMaster, sprinter, left, Allister Hutton, runner, 2nd left; Paul Forbes, runner, 3rd left;

Third row: Jackie Hynd, weightlifter 3rd from right, Brian Burgess, high jumper 2nd from right ; Willie Wood, bowler, in second row on the right.

Ronnie Hurst, diver,bottom far right;

1970 Willie Carmichael’s Games Gallery

Posted on July 19, 2017 by Admin

[Show slideshow]

1970 Extracts: 2. Gate Money

Posted on July 19, 2017 by Admin

Among the really big differences between the Games of 1970 and those of the 21st century, is the difference in the money involved. What I have added here is the money taken at the various venues for the Games. It was of course possible to buy tickets for particular sports and particular days so that most of those attending were either involved in active participation in the sports or former participants or supporters. Anyway, below are the pages which deal with ‘takings’ at the various venues.

1970 Extracts: 1. Tasks

Posted on July 19, 2017 by Admin

The Official History of the IXth British Commonwealth Games was compiled and edited by Willie Carmichael and M McIntyre Hood and was a very detailed account of the Games from conception to conclusion. We have here extracts from the history and begin with Sir Herbert Brechin’s intrduction. He was Lord Provost of Edinburgh at the time and had played a major part in the acquisition of the Games for Scotland. He says:

“The Games in Scotland, within the ancient capital city of Edinburgh, have taken place and the 15 years of overall preparation have concluded in a spectacle of which the British Commonwealth of nations can be justly proud. In a previous message I said ‘In all those arrangements we look forwrad to the 9th in the series of the Games being reckoned as being one of the most memorable in the series.

Many tens of thousands are now able to judge for themselves whether our hopes were fulfilled. From the record number of counmtries participating, from the record number of competitors and officials taking part and from the wave of enthusiasm which pressed over the country, I am convinced that the IXth Games will long be remembered as one of themost successful of the series.

The facilities provided, including the new modern Sports Centre at Meadowbank, and the advanced design of the new Commonwealth pool, allowed the competitors the fullest opportunity to participate and give of their best in their many skills. A great measure of the success of the Games lay in the pleasure all had in seeing HRH the Queen, HRH the Duke of Edinburgh, HRH the Prince of Wales and HRH the Princess Anne so happy in their midst. The Games were honoured in addition to the presence of the Royal Family by the way in which each participated. It was the first occasion in which HRH the Queen was present in person and the first occasion when the Queen presented medals in several of the Victory Ceremonies. Their obvious plesure and enjoyment during their visits quickly created that incomparable atmosphere which goes to create ‘The Friendly Games’, so aptly named by HRH the Duke of Edinburgh.

It would be impossible to detail completely all that was done to make the Games so memorable. The meticulous care and precision which went into the organisation and ceremonial of the Games, and which characterised these Games, was the result of perfect team-work by possibly the largest-ever team which operated over the four years of detailed organisation prior to the event. The British Government, the Local Authoprities of Scotland, the business houses in the commercial and industrial fields, the business people and individuals all combined in the accomplishment of this ideal.

The coming to Edinburgh and Scotland of so many thousands of people from so many countries of the world made the consummation of the final project possible by their presence. They rejoiced with us, they inspired us, and they left behind a fragrance of memory and happy association which will always stand high in the traditions of Scotland.

Sir Herbert Brechin

KBE, OL, JP, D Litt, FRICS, FRSE

As an example of the tasks that had to be addressed right at the start, extracts from pages 18 to 27 are copied below:

And so on with detailed instructions on the dates, venues and times of Royal visits to the many venues and events.

Queen’s Park Sports: 1907 – 1914

Posted on July 8, 2017 by Admin

The Queen’s Park Football Club Sports had been one of the best meetings in Scottish athletics as well as one of the first, they would also be one of the best athletic spectacles of the 20’s and 30’s, but there was a wee hiatus at the start of the twentieth century, for reasons to do with professionalism and corruption which are worthy of a separate page in their own right before the sports made their comeback in 1907. On this page we take a look at the sports after they started up again using only the Glasgow Herald coverage. Amateur athletics had been formally organised since 1883 with the founding of the SAAA and the first open athletics clubs appeared in 1885. There was continual friction between the two codes – amateurism and professionalism. There was no doubt about the corruption in professional athletics – and at times there was an overlap with prominent amateur athletes colluding with the pedestrians or even just emulating some of the worst practices.

The Glasgow Herald preview of the QPFC games in 1907 observed “Great changes have taken place in the Cathcart District since Queen’s Park last held sports. The residential population must be triple what it was in 1900, and with the amateur sentiment pre-eminent there is no reason why the Queen’s gathering on Saturday should not be as well patronised as any ordinary football match. It is no secret that there was a section of the mangement against holding sports, but on the other hand another section, perhaps the more progressive elements in committee, pointed out that the club, apart from fostering school football, did comparatively litle in promoting amateur sport, and in the long run it was agreed to revive what at one time was the most interesting function in the Scottish athletic season. The Queen’s are hopeful of having among their entrants several distinguished athletes, and JW Morton who is having a short holiday in Scotland, may take part in the two sprints.”

The sports took place on June 15th, 1907, and the report on them read as follows:

“QP SPORTS

If the revival of the Queen’s Park FC Sports failed to produce a renewal of public interest in amateur athletics the faultisnot theirs, for nothing finer in the way of competition has been seen at any city meeting this season. As a matter of fact the racing all round was exceptionally interesting, and at the same time was characterised by a keenness which must have recalled to many the earlier athletic festivals of our leading club. Amateur running has been largely cleansed of the excrescences which sullied it in the eyes of so many, and there is in the near future a beneficent career for this cult of athletics. The Hampden track was sodden, yet for all that the “times” in some instances were fast, and with careful handling and a little judicious expenditure there is no reason why the Queen’s ground should not be the home of athletic records.

Local support would be pleased when PR Grant, an old Queen’s Park back, won the 100 yards in 10 3/5th off 8 yards, the handicap mile was won by AB Hepburn with John McGough a yard behind, the schools relay was won by Allan Glen’s, the relay by Bellahouston Harriers. Judges reckoned that on a dry track with a clear run, McGough’s time would have been worth 4:20. The sports had returned and were a sporting success if not a financial one.

The QPFC Sports were held on 20th June 1908 and built upon those of the previous year, The Glasgow Herald report read as follows:

“Hampden is a fast track. This was made abundantly clear at the Queen’s Park Sports on Saturday. And were the same care and expense lavished on it that are lavished with no stinted hand on other parts of this great enclosure, it might be the fastest path in Scotland. Lieutenant Halswell placed an athletic record to the credit of Hampden on Saturday; in other words he invested new Hampden with the glory that circled old Hampden, as it was there that AR Downer rean 300 yards in 31 2/5th sec. Halswell reduced this by a fifth of a second. This looks rather mean in cold type, but its value is best measured by the fact that Downer’s time has held the field since 1895. That Halswell is a commanding personality in the athletic realm is now well known; he has given amateur pedestrianism a romanticism that it has not possessed since Downer was on the scene and it is the firm conviction of those who are versed in these matters that he will ere long gild his name with world’s record over the 300 and 440 yards distances. Last Thursday at Parkhead he won the quarter invitation handicap in the West of Scotland Harriers in 49 4/5th sec, this coupled with his all-comers record on Saturday constitutes great work.”

“Another fine performance was J Fairbairn-Crawford’s half-mile in 1 min 58 1/5th sec which is a second worse than his record in the Irish International at Ibrox two seasons ago. But in that race there was no one to interrupt his progress, whereas at Hampden he had to plough through a field of fifty. The fact is that Crawford would have run the race of his life on Saturdy had he been permitted to move freely. The race was won by Adam Turnbull (Clydesdale Harriers), 29 yards in 1 min 56 3/5th sec which is the finest display of running he has ever given

“Then the mile was the fastest – 4 min 21 4/5th sec – that has been run in Scotland this season. D Rutherford was the winner and , like Turnbull, he exhibited resources that few had credited him with. John McGough was not seen at his best; as a matter of fact it was obvious to all that he was running under physical disabilities. …. There was some very fine sprinting in the 100 yards and 220 yards. RC Duncan, a member of Queen’s Park, won the former from scratch in 10 2/5th sec, and the latter was captured by M Neilson, West of Scotland Harriers, 12 yards, in 22 4/5th secs.

The report was a bit longer and is worth reading, but these were the main results from a well organised meeting which also contained cycle racing and finished by saying

“The Queen’s Park may not have made a princely sum off their meeting on Saturday but they have the satisfaction of knowing that they have given the cause of athletics a much-needed lift in public favour.” The lack of a princely sum was maybe more significant than the report knew.

John McGough

Whatever the success of the 1908 meeting, 1909 turned out to be a disappointment – maybe for good reason. The Glasgow Herald of 7th June 1909 carried the following note: “Desirous that nothing should interfere with the success of the Australians visit to Partick Queen’s Park have abandoned their sports on June 19th. A proposal to this effect was submitted by the sub-committee entrusted with the arrangements and needless to say the General Committee cordially assented. Sports Meetings are everyday fare but cricket such as the Australians provide is a luxury.” In the cricket match on the 19th, the Australians of course won easily but the event was a great success. It is however a sign of the times that a football club would forego its athletic sports in favour of a cricket match.

Tom Jack

In contrast to the verdict in 1908, the report on the meeting of 18th June 1910 began: “Hampden Park will not be complete until the cinder path is in better order than it was on Saturday. Far too little attention has been given to this necessary and vital equipment but now that the Queen’s Park have come to recognise that it is part of their mission to foster amateur athletics it is just possible they will overhaul the track before another season comes round.”

As far as the performances were concerned: “While there was an absence of what one might term sensational performances at Hampden Park on Saturday, there was from the point of view of the student of athletics, what is perhaps more satisfactory, a pretty general excellence , exhibiting alike a highly creditable standard of efficiency and keen competitive emulation. Those features kept the spectators engrossed all the time and viewed therefore from whatever standpoint, the sports of the Queen’s Park Football Club were quite a success.”

The sports themselves had 100, 220, 880 yards races, one mile, two miles team race, schools relay race, obstacle race, highjump and several cycle races. The standard was high despite no records being broken –

eg Tom Jack, seven times Scottish 10 miles champion and cross country internationalist, won the half-mile and Mile,

Alex McPhee, SAAA four miles and cross-country champion in 1909, ran in the two miles,

RT Duncan, SAAA 100y and 220y champion and internationalist was off scratch in the sprints.

And an interesting competitor was Ralph Erskine of Allan Glen’s who was second in the high jump – he would go on to win the SAAA half mile title, become world lightweight boxing champion after winning the itle bout in New York before tragically being kille in action in January 1918.

1911 was the year of the Great Exhibition, a mammoth event encompassing all aspects of a civilised society. The Festival of Empire, or Great Exhibition, was held at the Crystal Palace in London from 12th May to celebrate the coronation of King George V. Wikipedia tells us thata pageant, organised by ‘Master of the Pageants’ Frank Lascelles, dramatising the history of London, England and the Empire was held. The first performance of the pageant was on 8 June 1911; in four parts, performed on separate days, it celebrated the ‘magnificence, glory and honour of the Empire and the Mother Country’. Music was provided for The Pageant of London by 20 composers including Ralph Vaughan Williams, Gustav Holst, Frank Bridge, Cecil Forsyth, Henry Balfour Gardiner, Edward German and Haydn Wood. This was performed by a military band of 50 players and a chorus of 500 voices. As part of the festival, an Inter-Empire sports championship was held in which teams from Australasia (a combined team from Australia and New Zealand), Canada, South Africa, and the United Kingdom competed in five athletics events (100 yards, 220 yards, 880 yards, 1 mile and 120 yards hurdles), two swimming events (100 yards and 1 mile), heavyweight boxing and middleweight wrestling. This is regarded as a forerunner of the British Empire Games (now Commonwealth Games), held from 1930.

In the Glasgow Herald of 15th May, 1911, the following appeared in the ‘Sports Miscellany’ column. “Queen’s Park FC have resolved not to hold sports this season. ” The date would be given to Paisley Harriers Juniors who were trying to raise the profile of the sport in their area but a week later, in the Herald of 22nd May, the Sports Miscellany reported that “It is just possible that the Queen’s Park Sports may come off after all. A proposal has been made by the West of Scotland Harriers which has found favour in influential circles, and the matter will be considered one of these days by the committee of the Queen’s Park. There has been considerable comment of an adverse kind at the decision of the Queen’s Park to abandon their meeting because of the opposition of the Exhibition, and it is now being felt that, all things considered, there was no justification, or at all events very little for cancelling the meeting. Should the proposal being made to the Queen’s Park result in the sports taking place, there will be general satisfaction in athletic circles as, after all, the amateur traditions of the old club carry with them a significance of which few, if any, other city functions can boast.”

The Paisley Junior Harriers meeting on the third Saturday in July was successful and the forecasts by the club and the Press were that they would continue to use this date which had hitherto been the property of the Queen’s Park. From reports, it would seem that unfortunately the QP sports did not in fact take place that year.

1912 did not look too promising either when the following appeared in the Herald: “The Queen’s Park FC have intimated to the Scottish Amateur Athletic Association that the new committee have decided not to hold sports on June 22nd – a date exclusively reserved for them by the Association. This means that the recommendation, if not the reasoned decision, of the old committeee has been rejected, and it also means a regrettable departure for the time being, if not for all time, from the line of policy in regard to amateur athletics which has won for Queen’s Park the admiration of all broad-minded sportsmen.”

The following week it was announced that on 22nd June, later than usual, Allan Glen’s School would hold their school championships at Hampden. This seemed to put the kybosh on any amateur sports s for 1912 sponsored by the football club at Hampden. By July the stuation had altered slightly and it was announced that the Queen’s Park FC confined sports would be held at Hampden in August. It is an interestingconcept – would it translate to present day football??? However, the Glasgow Herald of 15th July, 1912, had the following

“Queen’s Park FC are making an interesting departure early in August in connection with their own confined sports; they will include either two or three handicaps open to all-comers. It is just possible that the meeting will be sandwiched between the Rangers and Celtic functions, with the hope, no doubt, of getting one or two of the big guns who are coming to Glasgow for these meetings to show their paces. The Queen’s Park, to the great regret of many of their warmest supporters dropped their meeting in June, and it is by way of compensation for that disappointment that they are including a few open races at their club games next month. If the American and other Olympic competitors are in Glasgow during the first ten days of Augustit will be interesting to see if they are allured by the Hampden bait.”

On July 29th – “The Queen’s Park will run two open handicaps – 100 yards and 880 yards – in connection ith their club sports on Thursday first.”

It was at least a gesture, a move that the club did not have to make, but one that was welcomed by the sports loving public. The actual event wasn’t reported in the Herald which is hardly surprising give that it was at a very busy time of the year – ir Rangers Sports on the first Saturday and Monday of August and Celtic Sports on the second Saturday and Monday, as well as several well established meetings (eg Strathallan)
The club’s interest in athletics was still in evidence in 1913 when it was anounced that the Glasgow High School spots were to be held at Hampden. “This is a step in the right direction as Scotstoun is not very well adapted for school games. Besides there are interesting associations springing up between the High School and some of the older officials of the Queens Park club, and the closer the relations the greater the benefit both to the school and to QP.” (Herald, April 28th, 1913)

The sports were previewed on June 2nd, and after looking at some of the events, particularly the relays, it ended with a comment that “Mr Charles Stewart, who does a lot more for athletics in a general sense at the High School than most people are aware of, is again responsible for the arrangements and these, with the help hewill receive from members of Queen’s Park FC, should add to the enjoyment of the proceedings.”

The meeting was held the following Saturday with several, nor many, running events, some field events and several such as the drop kick, sack race (one each for former pupils and ‘open to school’), and 300 yards in football costume (confined to Glasgow High School FP FC).

Very interesting and the note on 28th April about relations with the High School is encouraging – but there is no note in the Herald of any sports meeting – open or confined – organised by Queen’s Park that year.

1914 saw the outbreak of War but a whole season was carried through before hostilities commenced. It was however another season without a Queen’s Park FC Sports meeting. They were involved in amateur sport throughout the season – The Queen’s Park School Sports were held at Hampden free of charge on 6th June, Allan Glen’s School sports were held on 20th June and then on 29th June it was reported that as hosts to the upcoming International between Scotland, England and Ireland, – QP are lavishing a deal of care on their cinder path at Hampden in view of the triangular athletics match there on July 11th. It already has one record – Halswell’s 300 yards- and there is no reason why it should not have more.”

With war looming, the August 224th Glasgow Herald announced that Queen’s Park had donated £250 to the Glasgow War Fund with a promise that more would be contributed if required. There had been no promoted meeting, but there had been a continuing presence of Queen’s Park in amateur athletics from schools sports to international fixtures.

We know that there were sports held by the club throughout the 1920’s but the on-again/off-again nature of the event in the period from 1900 to 1914 was strange in view of the other events reported at the time. The Queen’s Park was famous for its staunch adherence to the amateur code – a fact remarked upon in 1907 and 1908 when they were started up again. But the situation in Glasgow was not quite as clear cut as the SAAA might have us believe. For instance, the Glasgow Police Sports were accused of “Profesionalising Schoolboys” by having schools relays and sprint in their meeting on July 11th, Clyde FC were said to be “whole hoggers” when it came to professional athletics, indeed pre– and post-amateur athletics, there were weekly professional meetings at Shawfield with big crowds, biggish money prizes and quality professional athletes competing and there was a prominent note on “pedestrian development at Shawfield.” Even Celtic FC put on some mid-week professional athletic meetings. In such an atmosphere it might have been thought that Queen’s Park FC would have made a point of flying the amateur flag. There were hints of disagreements within the club committee on the merits of holding athletic sports and at the time of the start o the war, there had been none for two years.

The thread will be picked up in another post.